Health Education Research Advance Access originally published online on August 24, 2004
Health Education Research 2005 20(2):259-265; doi:10.1093/her/cyg116
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Health Education Research Vol.20 no.2, © Oxford University Press 2005; All rights reserved
Point of View |
Prevention of child obesity: First, do no harm
1 University of Sydney, Faculty of Education, Building A35, Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia
2 Correspondence to: J. A. O'Dea; E-mail: j.o'dea{at}edfac.usyd.edu.au
| Introduction |
|---|
The prevalence of child obesity has steadily increased in Western and developing countries over the last two decades, and child obesity prevention is now firmly on the agendas of nearly all major governments. We are now confronted with the challenge of what to do about the problem, and the general consensus among various academics, researchers, practitioners and administrators worldwide is that prevention needs to begin. Before governments and other agencies leap into actions that they assume to be beneficial in the battle against child obesity, we must remember to employ one of the most important principles of modern medicine and prevention science, First, do no harm.
An examination of potentially unhelpful or dangerous outcomes of child obesity prevention efforts is required before prevention activities begin. There are many examples of perfectly reasonable and well-intentioned health messages being partially misconstrued or misunderstood by members of the general public, resulting in the inadvertent production of undesirable effects in the implementation of supposedly health-promoting activities. The uptake of dieting and slimming among girls and young women is one example of a health message gone wrong. The moderate and sensible government dietary guideline of the late 1970s was taken up by the target audience who required it leastyoung women, who adhered to the control your weight message most vehemently. The exponential rise in disordered eating that followed these early messages has left health educators with the huge challenge of normalizing body image and eating behavior among a large proportion of our young population. The government message to control weight within reasonable limits was clearly exploited by cigarette advertisers who utilized the belief that cigarette smoking could be an effective slimming agent. This is an example of a health-related message going astray. What we failed to achieve as health educators, was to clarify this situation, that yes, controlling your weight is important, but not at the expense of other health behaviors. Multi-national corporations and marketers of the 1950s to 1980s clearly delivered the smoking is slimming message and this well entrenched way of thinking has placed current health educators in the uneasy predicament of having to encourage quitters to believe that the benefits of quitting despite the expected risk of weight gain outweigh the perceived benefits of slimness. A huge challenge indeed! Similarly, the early control your weight messages of the past, and those of today, clearly identify people who were overweight as failures, deviants or moral outcasts who needed some sort of treatment, most of which, when undertaken by the overweight person, resulted in further failure, defeat and humiliation, leaving us with the current prevalence of obesity of today. Is our message to overweight people and obese children any different today? Are our current preventive strategies any different or any more likely to succeed? To whom is child obesity prevention targeted? We must make certain that our preventive efforts are well conceived and based on a sound knowledge of prevention principles.
The first step in approaching any health education problem or planning any prevention program is to be very clear about what it is that we are trying to achieve and to have a clear definition of what we are trying to prevent. In the case of child obesity, we need to be clear from the outset that our role as health educators and prevention specialists is not in the diagnosis or treatment of child obesity.
| Prevention versus treatment |
|---|
Health professionals and health educators involved in the prevention of child obesity need to understand the difference between treatment and prevention. The treatment of child obesity should only occur in a supervised clinical setting after a thorough and appropriate clinical assessment. Prescription of weight control programs, dietary advice or other individual interventions for the obese child should remain the role of the pediatrician, general practitioner, dietitian or other clinically trained staff. Community-based professionals such as health educators, nutritionists, nurses, teachers, youth workers, sports coaches and others working with children and youth must understand the difference between child obesity treatment and prevention, and must act accordingly using appropriate referrals without confusing their clinical and community roles. Health and education professionals should also be acutely aware of the fact that a child's health status encompasses several different dimensions including physical, mental, social and spiritual health, and not merely the absence of disease. Likewise, the absence of obesity does not necessarily ensure a healthy child. Child obesity prevention should not dominate the overall picture of child health. There are many essential aspects of child health, including sound nutrition for growth, development, immunity, brain function; physical activity for health and well-being; social support; safety; immunization and accident prevention to name a few. Weight control is only one aspect of overall child health, yet it appears to be dominating the current perspective of health education and health promotion initiatives aimed at children and adolescents. In addition to defining child health within broader parameters than mere weight status, health educators must also be very careful to Do no harm to any of these essential dimensions of health in their efforts to treat or prevent child obesity.
| Inadvertent suggestion of dieting and other weight loss techniques |
|---|
Health and education professionals who work in the treatment and prevention of child obesity also need to be aware of the fact that their best intentions may have the potential to inadvertently do more harm than good. The unintentional creation of body image and weight concerns, dieting, disordered eating and eating disorders is a probable outcome of child obesity prevention programs that focus on the problem of overweight and refer to issues of weight control. The vast majority of overweight children and adolescents know that they are fat and subsequently develop a poor body image and a fear of food (O'Dea et al., 1995; Neumark-Sztainer et al., 2002
Health education for child obesity prevention may also result in the iatrogenesis of inappropriate weight control techniques whereby the health education program generates unplanned, undesirable and health-damaging effects (Garner, 1985; O'Dea, 2000) such as starvation, vomiting, laxative abuse, diuretic and slimming pill usage, and cigarette smoking to suppress appetite and as a substitute for eating (Ikeda and Mitchell, 2001
; Strauss and Mir, 2001
). Obese children and their parents may misinterpret media reports about child obesity and other weight control messages as a cue for seeking quick fix fad weight loss diets, diet products and weight loss regimes, all of which are unsuitable for growing children.
| Avoid further stigmatization, prejudice and discrimination |
|---|
Child obesity prevention programs and untested health education messages have the potential to further stigmatize fat children (Latner and Stunkard, 2003
In addition to obese children of both sexes being well aware of their weight problems, they also have low self-esteem (Strauss, 2000
), and are currently known to exhibit high rates of extreme dieting, disordered eating and skipping breakfast (Croll et al., 2002
) as well as greater levels of emotional distress and lower expectations of their educational futures (Mellin et al., 2002
). The last thing that obese children need is a reminder of their undesirable weight status.
In addition to the further stigmatization of overweight children by focusing on the dangers of obesity and other negatively focused health messages, health educators may also inadvertently discriminate against overweight children by excluding them from general participation in certain events such as school games and sports teams. This type of discrimination is known to effect overweight and obese adults who suffer discrimination in terms of employment, salary, promotion, education, marriage and healthcare (Gortmaker et al., 1993
). Conversely, forcing unwilling participation is likely to have the undesirable outcome of making overweight children avoid physical activity.
| Transference and misinformation |
|---|
Health professionals may need to examine their own beliefs and attitudes towards fat people and fat children before embarking on any child obesity prevention activities, and they may need specific training in order to undertake any role in child obesity prevention. The potential for inadvertent transference of misinformation, inappropriate advice and prejudice from educator to child needs to be examined during the design of health education and health promotion strategies for the prevention of child overweight. In a recent study of the teachers most likely to be involved in school-based obesity prevention activities, we found a low level of nutrition knowledge and knowledge of weight control, a great deal of misinformation being conveyed from teacher to students, and a very high level of body dissatisfaction and self-reported eating disorders, particularly among the young women teachers (O'Dea and Abraham, 2001
| Undesirable outcomes of unplanned approaches |
|---|
Of similar potential danger in the prevention of child obesity is the dissemination of messages, whether intentional or not, that have not been properly designed, pre-tested and evaluated. In an evaluation of two posters aimed at improving the body image of teenaged girls and young women (O'Dea, 2002
| Avoidance of health services and preventive screening tests |
|---|
As a consequence of weight prejudice and discrimination, overweight adults, particularly women, are less likely to visit health professionals for preventive health screening examinations such as mammograms, pap smear tests and gynecologic examinations (Fontaine et al., 1998
| Further promoting the avoidance of physical activity |
|---|
Highlighting the problem of overweight in prevention programs aimed at children and adolescents is likely to produce the adverse effect of making overweight children more sensitive about their weight and their self perceived lack of athletic ability (O'Dea and Abraham, 1999), and therefore making them less likely to participate in physical activity, physical education and sport (Shaw and Kemeny, 1989
| Blaming the victim |
|---|
The current panic about child obesity is largely fuelled by media reports that focus on the rising prevalence of child overweight and its potential health problems. The problem-based, negatively and individually focused, victim-blaming approach is something that health educators ought to avoid, as it is likely to result in nothing more than the apportioning of more blame, guilt, shame and hopelessness on fat children and their parents. As these negative reinforcing factors have not been previously associated with any degree of long term success in the past treatment or prevention of overweight in children or adults (Garner and Wooley, 1991
| Further marginalizing people of low socioeconomic status (SES) |
|---|
The prevalence of overweight is greater among socially and economically disadvantaged people, and the association between lower SES and obesity is well documented (Sobal and Stunkard, 1989
| Obesity as a sick role |
|---|
As effective health educators, we also need to be aware of promoting child obesity as a sick role that needs medical treatment. Sound nutrition and physical activity are essential components for overall child health as they convey many wide ranging benefits for growth, development, brain development and cognition, immunity, and disease preventionnot just child obesity prevention. All children need good nutrition and physical activity, not just obese children.
The medicalization of child obesity will do little to reduce it, as the failure of dietary treatments for overweight have already demonstrated many times (Garner and Wooley, 1991
). The prescription of drug treatments for obese children is increasing, lending further credibility to the myth that obesity can be cured with a quick fix drug treatment. At least one professional organization of which the author is aware has suggested that participants and groups involved in child obesity prevention should disclose all special interests such as financial affiliations with pharmaceutical companies or the weight loss industry (Berg, 2000
; Society for Nutrition Education, 2002
). It is of serious concern that the child obesity debate and preventive activities among children could be influenced by those aiming to make profits out of child obesity treatment or prevention.
| The need for a new paradigm |
|---|
A different paradigm to the individual, dieting, weight loss approach for the treatment and prevention of obesity in adults has been proposed (Robison et al., 1995
| Use of sound health education theory |
|---|
Finally, we urgently need a positive health education approach grounded in sound health education theory in order to properly plan, design, implement and evaluate the most appropriate, relevant and effective child obesity prevention strategies. Much is currently known about the factors that motivate healthy eating and physical activity among children and adolescents (O'Dea, 2003
Child obesity prevention is an important contemporary health education topic that is not going to subside for a very long time. The aim of this Point of View is not to provide all of the answers for child obesity prevention, but rather to question our current health education approaches, and to investigate the possibility that some of our most well-meaning preventive intentions may be potentially hazardous and more likely to be harmful than beneficial to the overweight child. As health education experts, we are obliged to approach the issue of child obesity prevention with a broad perspective and a thorough preventive focus, and we initially need to ensure that our preventive efforts must be certain to do no harm.
| References |
|---|
Berg, F.M. (2000) How the diet industry exerts control. In: Berg, F.M. and Rosencrans, K. (eds), Women Afraid to Eat. Healthy Weight Network, Hettinger, ND, pp.193211.
Blair, S.N. (2003) Revisiting fitness and fatness as predictors of mortality. Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine, 13, 319320.[CrossRef][Medline]
Bonjour, J., Theintz, G., Buchs, S.B., Slosman, D. and Rizzoli, R. (1991) Critical years and stage of puberty for spinal and femoral bone mass accumulation during adolescence. Journal of Clinical and Endocrinological Metabolism, 73, 555563.
Brook. C., Lloyd. J. and Wolff. O. (1974) Rapid weight loss in children. British Medical Journal, 3, 4445.
Croll, J., Neumark-Sztainer, D., Story, M. and Ireland, M. (2002) Prevalence and risk and protective factors related to disordered eating behaviors among adolescents: relationship to gender and ethnicity. Journal of Adolescent Health, 31, 166175.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Davis, D., Apley, G., Fill, G. and Grimaldi, C. (1978) Diet and retarded growthmedical cases of 36 British children. British Medical Journal, 1, 539542.[ISI][Medline]
Dhuper, S., Warren, M.P., Brooks-Gunn, J. and Fox, R. (1990) Effects of hormonal status on bone density in adolescent girls. Journal of Clinical and Endocrinological Metabolism, 71, 10831088.
Fontaine, K.R., Faith, M.S., Allison, D.B. and Cheskin, L.J. (1998) Body weight and health care among women in the general population. Archives of Family Medicine, 7, 381384.
Foster, G.D., Wadden, T.A., Makris, A.P., Davidson, D., Sanderson, R.S., Allison, D.B. and Kessler, A. (2003) Primary car physicians' attitudes about obesity and its treatment. Obesity Research, 10, 11681177.
Frisch, R.E., Wyshak, G. and Vincent, L. (1980) Delayed menarche and amenorrhoea of ballet dancers, New England Journal of Medicine, 303, 1719.[ISI][Medline]
Garner, D.M. (1988) Intragenesis in anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 4, 701726.
Garner, D.M. and Wooley, S.C. (1991) Confronting the failure of behavioural and dietary treatments for obesity. Clinical Psychology Review, 11, 729780.[CrossRef][ISI]
Goodman, E. (2003) Letting the gini out of the bottle: social causation and the obesity epidemic. Journal of Pediatrics, 142, 228230.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Gortmaker, S.L., Must, A., Perrin, J.M., Sobal, A.M. and Dietz, W.H. (1993) Social and economic consequences of overweight in adolescence and young adulthood. New England Journal of Medicine, 329, 10081012.
Gracey, D., Stanley, N., Burke, V., Corti, B. and Bellin, L.J. (1996) Nutritional knowledge, beliefs and behaviours in teenage school students. Health Education Research, 11, 187204.
Ikeda, J.P. and Mitchell, R.A. (2001) Dietary approaches to the treatment of the overweight pediatric patient. Pediatric Clinics of North America, 48, 955968.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Kulin, H., Bwibo, N., Mutie, D. and Santner, S. (1982) The effects of chronic childhood malnutrition on pubertal growth and development. American Journal Clinical Nutrition, 35, 527536.
Latner, J.D. and Stunkard, A. (2003) Getting worse: stigmatization of obese children. Obesity Research, 11, 452456.[ISI][Medline]
Lev-Ran, A. (1974) Secondary amenorrhoea resulting from uncontrolled weight reduction diets. Fertility and Sterility, 25, 459462.[ISI][Medline]
Lifshitz, F. and Moses, N. (1988) Nutritional dwarfing: growth, dieting and fear of obesity. Journal American College Nutrition, 7, 367376.
Lifshitz, F. and Moses, N. (1989) A complication of dietary treatment of hypercholesterolaemia. American Journal of Diseases in Children, 143, 537542.
Maddox, G.L. and Liederman, V. (1969) Overweight as a social disability with medical implications. Journal of Medical Education, 44, 214220.[ISI][Medline]
Mallick, M.J. (1983) Health hazards of obesity and weight control in children: a review of the literature. American Journal Public Health, 73, 7882.
Mellin, A.E., Neumark-Sztainer, D., Story, M., Ireland, M. and Resnick, M.D. (2002) Unhealthy behaviours and psychosocial difficulties among overweight adolescents: the potential impact of familial factors. Journal of Adolescent Health, 31, 145153.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Neumark-Sztainer, D., Story, M., Perry, C. and Casey, M.A. (1999) Factors influencing food choices of adolescents: Findings from focus group discussions with adolescents. Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 99, 929934.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Neumark-Sztainer, D., Story, M., Hannan, P.J., Perry, C.L. and Irving, L.M. (2002) Weight related concerns and behaviours among overweight and nonoverweight adolescents. Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine, 156, 171178.
Olson, C.L., Schumaker, H.D. and Yawn, B.P. (1994) Overweight women delay medical care. Archives of Family Medicine, 3, 888892.[Abstract]
O'Dea, J. (2002) Can body image education be harmful to adolescent females? Eating Disorders, 10, 113.
O'Dea, J. (2003) Why do kids eat healthful food? Perceived benefits of and barriers to healthful eating and physical activity among children and adolescents. Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 103, 497501.[ISI][Medline]
O'Dea, J. and Abraham, S. (2001). Knowledge, beliefs, attitudes and behaviours related to weight control, eating disorders and body image in Australian trainee home economics and physical education teachers, Journal of Nutrition Education, 33, 332340.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
O'Dea, J. and Maloney, D. (2001) Preventing eating and body image problems in children and adolescents using the Health Promoting Schools Framework. Journal of School Health, 70, 1821.
O'Dea, J., Abraham, S. and Heard, R. (1996) Food habits, body image and weight control practices of young male and female adolescents. Australian Journal of Nutrition and Dietetics, 53, 3238.
Ott, S.M. (1991) Bone density in adolescents. New England Journal of Medicine, 325, 16461647.[ISI][Medline]
Piran, N. (1999) Prevention in a high-risk environment: an intervention in a ballet school. In Piran, N., Levine, M.L. and Steiner-Adair, C. (eds), Preventing Eating Disorders: A Handbook of Interventions and Special Challenges. Brunner/Mazel, New York, pp. 148159.
Powell, K.E., Bricker, S.K. and Blair, S.N. (2002) Treating inactivity. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 23(Suppl. 1), 12.[ISI][Medline]
Pugliese, M., Lifshitz, F., Grad, G., Fort, P. and Marks-Katz, M. (1983) Fear of obesity: a cause of short stature and delayed puberty. New England Journal of Medicine, 309, 513518.[Abstract]
Rayner, P. and Court, J., (1974) The effect of dietary restriction and anorectic drugs on linear growth velocity in childhood obesity. Archives of Diseases in Children, 49, 822823.[ISI][Medline]
Robison, J.I., Hoerr, S.L., Petersmarck, K.A. and Anderson, J.V. (1995) Redefining success in obesity intervention: the new paradigm. Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 95, 422423.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Shaw, S.M. and Kemeny, L. (1989) Fitness promotion for adolescent girls: the impact and effectiveness of promotional material which emphasises the slim ideal. Adolescence, 24, 677687.[ISI][Medline]
Sobal, J. and Stunkard, A.J. (1989) Socioeconomic status and obesity: a review of the literature. Psychological Bulletin, 105, 260275.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Society For Nutrition Education (2002) Guidelines for Childhood Obesity Prevention Programs: Promoting Healthy Weight in Children. Available: http://www.sne.org.
Strauss, R.S. (2000) Childhood obesity and self-esteem. Pediatrics, 105(1). Available: http://www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/105/1/e15.
Strauss, R.S. and Mir, H.M. (2001) Smoking and weight loss attempts in overweight and normal-weight adolescents. International Journal of Obesity and Related Metabolic Disorders, 25, 13811385.
Strauss, R.S. and Pollack, H.A. (2003) Social marginalization of overweight children. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 157, 746752.
Theintz, G.E., Howald, H., Weiss, U. and Sizonenko, C. (1993) Evidence for a reduction of growth potential in adolescent female gymnasts. Journal of Pediatrics, 122, 306313.[ISI][Medline]
Young, L.M. and Powell, B. (1985) The effects of obesity on the clinical judgements of health care professionals. Journal of Health Sociology and Behavior, 26, 233246.
Wee, C.C., McCarthy, E.P., Davis, R.B. and Phillips, R.S. (2004) Obesity and breast cancer screening. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 19, 324331.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Received on May 24, 2004; accepted on July 12, 2004
![]()
CiteULike
Connotea
Del.icio.us What's this?
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
F. A. Carter and C. M. Bulik Childhood Obesity Prevention Programs: How Do They Affect Eating Pathology and Other Psychological Measures? Psychosom Med, April 1, 2008; 70(3): 363 - 371. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. W. Lowry, B. J. Sallinen, and D. M. Janicke The Effects of Weight Management Programs on Self-Esteem in Pediatric Overweight Populations J. Pediatr. Psychol., November 1, 2007; 32(10): 1179 - 1195. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. P. Ikeda, P. B. Crawford, and G. Woodward-Lopez BMI screening in schools: helpful or harmful Health Educ. Res., December 1, 2006; 21(6): 761 - 769. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Minerva BMJ, June 11, 2005; 330(7504): E361 - E361. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Minerva BMJ, April 2, 2005; 330(7494): 798 - 798. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||



